Pope Francis Removes Bishop of Tyler, Texas for Criticizing Pontiff and Polarizing U.S. Catholic Hierarchy

Pope Francis Removes Conservative Bishop of Tyler, Texas, Sparking Controversy

In a surprising move, Pope Francis has ordered the removal of Bishop Joseph Strickland of Tyler, Texas, a conservative prelate known for his active presence on social media and his criticism of the pontiff. The decision has highlighted the deep polarization within the U.S. Catholic hierarchy.

The Vatican’s one-line statement announced that Francis had relieved Bishop Strickland of his pastoral governance in Tyler and appointed the bishop of Austin as the temporary administrator. Strickland, 65, has been a vocal critic of Francis, accusing him of undermining the deposit of faith and disagreeing with the pontiff on various issues, including the treatment of LGBTQ+ Catholics.

Earlier this year, the Vatican sent investigators to look into Strickland’s governance of the diocese amid complaints from priests and laypeople. Despite the Vatican’s findings, Strickland refused to resign voluntarily, citing his mandate from the late Pope Benedict XVI.

One of the reasons given for Strickland’s removal was his refusal to implement Francis’ restrictions on celebrating the old Latin Mass, a decision that has been controversial among traditionalist Catholics. Strickland stood by his choice, stating that he couldn’t starve out part of his flock.

The news of Strickland’s removal has sparked outcry among some conservatives and traditionalists, who viewed him as a symbol of resistance against Francis’ progressive reforms. The Vatican’s decision to remove Strickland without his resignation is rare and signifies a significant rift within the U.S. Catholic hierarchy.

In a statement, Cardinal Daniel DiNardo of Texas confirmed that the Vatican’s investigation recommended Strickland’s removal, leading to Francis’ decision. The pope’s action reflects his concerns about the right-wing faction within the U.S. Catholic hierarchy and their resistance to change.

Despite the controversy, the diocese of Tyler assured that its work would continue, emphasizing its mission to share the Gospel and serve the needs of all people. The incoming temporary administrator, Bishop Joe Vásquez, pledged to assess the diocese’s needs and asked for prayers during the transition.

The removal of Bishop Strickland underscores the ongoing tensions within the Catholic Church and the challenges of reconciling differing viewpoints within the hierarchy. The incident serves as a reminder of the complexities and divisions present in the modern Catholic Church.